JU-ON: THE GRUDGE
Written and directed by Takashi Shimizu
With Megumi Okina, Misako Ito, Misi Uehara, Yui Ichikawa
(Note: this review appears in the latest issue of
CINEMA SCOPE, but the magazine doesn't have a website at present.)
When a film stops making sense, it can be scary. JU-ON: THE GRUDGE bases
its terror around that feeling of being lost in an incomprehensible narrative.
Its characters are plunged into a haunted house’s world of shadows, curses
and homicidal ghosts, and we go there along with them. Its achronological
structure wouldn’t be unusual for an art film, but it’s pretty unique in a
horror film. (Hideo Nakata’s 1999 thriller CHAOS is the most recent Japanese
counterpart.) Divided into six parts, each named after a different character,
the film requires us to follow it without the usual comforts of conventional
storytelling: characters with whom one can easily identify and narrative closure.
The nominal protagonist appears in only three parts, and the spectator has
to wait half an hour before finding out what happened to her after the first
part. The fifth section, named for the teenage girl Izumi, runs about five
minutes before we learn her connection to the house.
This version of JU-ON:THE GRUDGE is a remake, a successor to two straight-to-video
productions with the same premise and name. The videos weren’t
too popular at first, but they eventually found enough of a cult audience
to warrant a theatrical version. JU-ON: THE GRUDGE 2 was released in Japan
earlier this year. Slicker, more prosaic and even grimmer, it revolves around
a TV shoot in the haunted house. Unfortunately, it indulges ill-advised concepts
like a haunted copy machine and an attack by a crawling wig. Coming this fall
will be Shimizu’s Americanized remake, produced by Sam Raimi and starring
Sarah Michelle Gellar but set in the same house. Even if the same director
is behind the controls, it’s hard to picture a Hollywood genre film with the
In the first part of JU-ON: THE GRUDGE, Rika (Megumi Okina) volunteers at
a welfare office. She’s handed the case file left over when a colleague went
missing. Going to her clients’ house, she opens the door and sees shoes scattered
all over the living room. After she hears clanking, she discovers a near-catatonic
elderly woman behind a door. She then hears rustling in a closet. Thinking
that it’s just a cat, she opens the door and sees a little boy. The elderly
woman rises slightly from her passive state to repeatedly mutter “I told her
again and again” as she rocks back and forth. A specter attacks her, and
turns her attentions to Rika. She passes out, as the boy watches. Then
the second section, which actually precedes it chronologically, begins.
Many recent Japanese horror films show a fear of technology, perhaps derived
from the enormous shadow of Nakata’s RING. (Its screenwriter served
as a “creative consultant” on JU-ON: THE GRUDGE, along with Kiyoshi Kurosawa).
Shimizu addresses some of these concerns in its third and weakest section,
“Hitomi.” A mixed bag, it includes some striking images but relies on a character
acting like an idiot by lying in bed waiting for ghosts to come after her.
A guard literally turns to dust on a security camera video. (We later see
more of it, culminating in an image of all-consuming darkness, save for a
pair of menacing eyes.) Hitomi turns on the TV to relax, but an innocuous
report about birds gets distorted into a still reminiscent of Edward Munch’s
“The Scream.” The ghosts are able to impersonate her brother-in-law on the
phone and at her door.
There’s no on-screen violence in JU-ON: THE GRUDGE - unless the guard’s
disappearance counts - but Shimizu’s visual restraint goes well beyond merely
avoiding gore. He never uses an image if a sound would do. He delays the
appearance of ghosts as long as possible, signaling ominous events with noise.
His tracking shots suggest someone craning their neck, struggling to see
something just out of their sightline. The simple task of opening a
door cranks up tension. Although sometimes heavyhanded, the score effectively
layers orchestral and electronic drones to create an atmosphere of terror.
While JU-ON: THE GRUDGE draws on several Nakata films, it reminds
me more of THE BLAIR WITCH PROJECT, both in its use of offscreen space and
its vision of youthful optimism - encompassing female independence
and faith in technology - confronting the supernatural and failing miserably.
Here, the young are put on the chopping block, sacrificed to “pay” for a distant
murder. (As much as THE EXORCIST, it pivots around fear of children. JU-ON:
THE GRUDGE 2 takes this theme even further.) Family ties are deadly,
since the haunting spreads like the flu. Hitomi “catches” it from her brother-in-law,
whom she visits in the second part. Some of the film’s final images recall
the glacial chill of the coda to Michelangelo Antonioni’s L’ECLISSE: a world
stripped of humanity and reduced to a collection of objects and uninhabited
places. A grim worldview, it’s one that Shimizu puts across with tremendous