| Yearly | Finals | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 Romans | Sarah Fortner | Michael Roberts | ||||
| 2005 Matthew | Sarah Fortner | Amanda Falligan | ||||
| 2004 Hebrews | Jordan Utley | Tommy Byler | ||||
| 2003 John | Brandon Foskey | Brandon Foskey | ||||
| 2002 Corinthians | Jordan Utley | Brandon Foskey | ||||
| 2001 Luke | Jordan Utley/Rob Bice | Brandon Foskey | ||||
| 2000 Galatians | Celia Fortner | Celia Fortner | ||||
| 1999 Acts | Melinda Crum | Melinda Crum | ||||
| 1998 Romans | Abby Brantley | Abby Brantley/Christy Hitchcock | ||||
| 1997 Matthew | Tabitha Daugherty | Tabitha Daugherty | ||||
| 1996 Hebrews | Landon Marshall | Landon Marshall | ||||
| 1995 John | Glenn Harper | Glenn Harper | ||||
| 1994 Corinthians | Christy Nicodemus | Jeremy Carter | ||||
| 1993 Luke | Glenn Harper | |||||
| 1992 Galatians | Glenn Harper |