Ringworld Modal Analysis Results
Peter A. Taylor
May 24, 2003
Here are some estimates for some of the lowest natural frequencies of vibration of the Ringworld and their vibration mode shapes in a coordinate system that rotates with the Ringworld. Note that these are not shock waves or other high frequency waves. These are the lowest frequencies. If you think of the Ringworld as being like a curved violin string with no endpoints, I am trying to estimate the lowest pitch it can make, not the sound of it being smashed by a punk rocker.
If you want to skip a longwinded explanation, scroll down to the link labelled "mode1." Otherwise....
In order to get a feel for what I am trying to calculate, and the effect of the rotating reference frame, forget the violin string analogy for a moment and imagine that you're riding a merry-go-round while trying to play tetherball. If you pull the tetherball outward from its equilibrium position (away from the merry-go-round's center) and push it forward (in the direction the merry-go-round is moving), the tetherball will appear to move in a circle. This is shown in the figure, tetherball1.
The large dotted circle shows the tetherball's equilibrium point moving relative to the merry-go-round's pivot. The long red line connects the pivot to the equilibrium point. The short red line connects the equilibrium point to the ball's current position, the arrow shows the ball's current velocity, and the small circle shows the ball's path around its equilibrium point. As is true of all of these figures, the displacements have been scaled to make them look good, so don't try to read anything into the scale; it is arbitrary.
In this "pure" mode of oscillation, the ball does not pass through its equilibrium position, but circles around it (it is not "harmonic"). This makes it complicated to draw the ball's path. The way the math works out, I get pairs of solutions that represent the ball's position at two different times in its cycle, 90 degrees out of phase. In some ways it is easier to think of these two solutions as different phases of the same mode of vibration, but in other ways it is easier to think of them as a pair of different modes that happen to share the same frequency. I show this in my next figure, tetherball2.
We could just as easily push the ball backwards, opposite to the merry-go-round's rotation. But there is a difference. In the forward case, the ball's rotation and the merry-go-round's rotation add. In the backward case, they subtract. So the periods of the motions in the two directions will be different. For this "tetherball" example (actually assuming linear springs rather than a dangling rope), the frequency of motion in the posigrade direction already shown was 8.198 radians/second and in the retrograde direction was 12.198 radians/second. The second pair of vectors is shown in the next figures, tetherball3 and tetherball4.
In real life, we usually don't see pure modes like these circles, but combinations of several modes at once. An event like the Fist of God impact will put energy into many modes simultaneously. You'll notice that to get these pure "tetherball" modes, I had to displace the ball and then push it forward or back. If I had just pushed it without first displacing it, I would have excited two modes at once, and would have gotten a more complicated motion that did swing back through the equilibrium point, but didn't quite repeat itself on the next swing. The two modes vibrate at different frequencies, and so the tendencies to swing clockwise and counterclockwise don't quite cancel. We then see, in an exaggerated form, the familiar motion of a Foucault pendulum mounted well away from the Earth's equator:
Now let's talk about the Ringworld. I made a number of important assumptions:
All frequencies are in radians/second. The ring rotation rate (omega) corresponds to a period of 9 days. The period of the first mode is 21.4 days.
|1, 2, 3, 4:||3.391208E-6||3.391208E-6||1.494779E-5||1.494779E-5|
|5, 6, 7, 8:||1.648368E-5||1.648368E-5||2.501163E-5||2.501163E-5|
|9, 10, 11, 12:||2.579653E-5||2.579653E-5||3.396396E-5||3.396396E-5|
|13, 14, 15, 16:||3.650952E-5||3.650952E-5||4.345375E-5||4.345375E-5|
|17, 18, 19, 20:||4.747975E-5||4.747975E-5||5.356643E-5||5.356643E-5|
|21, 22, 23, 24:||5.889438E-5||5.889438E-5||6.429545E-5||6.429545E-5|
|25, 26, 27, 28:||7.069410E-5||7.069410E-5||7.543140E-5||7.543140E-5|
|29, 30, 31, 32:||8.243244E-5||8.243244E-5||8.638629E-5||8.638629E-5|
|1, 2, 3, 4:||21.44429||21.44429||4.865072||4.865072|
|5, 6, 7, 8:||4.411762||4.411762||2.907530||2.907530|
|9, 10, 11, 12:||2.819063||2.819063||2.141153||2.141153|
|13, 14, 15, 16:||1.991866||1.991866||1.673551||1.673551|
|17, 18, 19, 20:||1.531644||1.531644||1.357605||1.357605|
|21, 22, 23, 24:||1.234788||1.234788||1.131061||1.131061|
|25, 26, 27, 28:||1.028686||1.028686||0.9640820||0.9640820|
|29, 30, 31, 32:||0.8822019||0.8822019||0.8418240||0.8418240|
The mode shapes: The red near-circles (24-sided figures) are the undeformed shapes. The green figures are exaggerated deformed shapes. The dotted ellipses are the paths of the deformed nodes. Short red lines connect the undeformed node positions to the deformed positions. Red arrows show the velocities of the nodes.
The first mode (two phase angles): It looks elliptical, but notice that it rolls around the Ring like a tetherball rather than having the eccentricity grow or shrink. My "mode 2" is 90 degrees behind "mode 1."
Here's what they look like with phase angle offsets of 45 degrees:
Here's the next mode pair. Oddly, this three-cornered posigrade mode has a lower frequency than the retrograde elliptical mode that I was expecting would be next:
The other shoe finally drops. Here's that retrograde elliptical mode:
And here is the expected retrograde three-cornered mode pair.
Now they start to come in a predictable pattern. Here are the four-cornered posigrade and retrograde modes:
Here is a pentacle for Carol (mode 13 with a 190 degree phase angle offset):
Here is some striking visual evidence that the "Tnuctipun plot" that has been bandied about on the Niven list is wrong. The Ringworld appears to have been built by the lost tribe of Israel as some sort of signaling device.
Or maybe by the Sheriff's Department?
A predictable eight-pointed star:
Or was it built by the Ba'hai?
As you can see, 24 nodes isn't enough to get good representations of these more complicated mode shapes. But it seems good enough for the first handful.
Or maybe not. You know, I think we should build one and test it....