REPLY #12 TO|
"EVOLUTION VS. CREATIONISM"
Boldfaced statements are parts of the original essay (or a subsequent reply) to which the respondent has directed his comments.
Italicized/emphasized comments prefaced by (R) are those of the respondent and are presented unedited.
My replies appear under the respondent's comments in blue text and are prefaced by my initials (MB).
(R) You ask for proof of God. What would you accept as proof ?
(MB) How about showing me just one thing in the Universe that could only exist
if it had been created by God? How about describing God for me in such a way
that there can be no doubt that he exists? How about telling me why those who
believe in God have the story "right" and why those who believe in other deities
have the story "wrong"?
(R) SETI when searching for intelligent life in the universe looks for patterns.
(MB) Because any communication signal that would be produced by an intelligent
civilization would not be random noise if it contained any coherent data. Even
if we didn't understand the language being spoken, there would still be
discernable patterns embedded within it.
(R) because patterns do not happen in a random basis. There must be an
intelligence behind it.
(MB) Patterns could happen by coincidence. After all, a "pattern" is just
another of the numerous possible arrangements of things. We also tend to see
(or invent) patterns simply because we are looking to find them. That's why
people "see things" in the essentially random shapes of clouds, for example.
If we received a short and non-repeating SETI signal in which we found a
pattern, that would not be conclusive evidence that it originated from the
actions of an intelligent being.
(R) Therefore, please explain how life which is a very complex pattern came
about. And I am not talking about the basic building blocks which you say are
self organizing, explain how the human eye could be chance, or the human hand.
(MB) You can't discount the self-organizing components of life. Without them,
there *is* no life. All else is produced by the accumulation of mutations
during the reproduction and assembly of those components -- including the human
eye and hand.
The eye has evolved at least 8 different times throughout the various species of animals. In some species, it is very advanced. In others, it is still a primitive structure. To read more about this, select the link below.
[Read about the evolution of the eye and color vision]
Created with Allaire HomeSite 4.0 .......... Last Update: 04 Jun 98
Earthlink Network Home Page
Go to next reply
Return to "Evolution vs. Creationism" essay
Back to Philosophy page