Ms. Craig's 4th Grade Class
e-mails: South Bend, Indiana
*I liked the chapter sixteen. I
thought it was scary and
funny. -Jordan
*Cynthia's Attic is my favorite chapter book. I
really liked the book. It was very exciting. My favorite chapter is chapter 16. -Blake
*I thought the book was funny and interesting,
it starts
to get interesting at the end.
-Jasimine
*My favorite part of the story (was) when
the girls meet the dead boy in the story. -Wisdom
*What I liked (was) the part when they find
the locket. -Austin
*I liked when they met Andre. Why
did Andre turn bad? -Nick
*The book was very interesting and mysterious. My
favorite part was when Gus picked up the apple and was going to throw it at the waitress. -Korey
*This is what I think of your story...I like
this story really good. I like it when
Cynthia got into the pink pretty
ballerina dress. I like ballerina dresses too.
-Sincerely, Your fourth grade
friend, Katlyn
*I love your story. It is fun to
read. Hope you make
another one. I know it's
going to be great. -Jessenia
*Cynthia's Attic is a great book. I
love the part when Cynthia knocks Andre into the lifeboat. I also like the part when Gus picks up the apple and
it looks like the
apple is floating. -Ben
*Why did Andre cheat on Belle and then want
a second chance? Then if he loved her why did he try to kill her? I have one more question,
how were the clothes able to get them to the past? The thing that I like about the book
is that they have a lot of adventures. I never have had an adventure in my life. -Paige
*I really like the book. I like
when they threw the apple at his head. -Elijah
*I love your book, Cynthia's Attic. My
favorite part is when Gus meets Aunt
Belle. -Bryant
*I liked Gus's attitude! I also
liked when Cynthia and Gus met the "dead"
guy!!!-ha ha ha-My favorite part
was when Cynthia knocked Andre into the
lifeboat. -Brandon
*I loved Cynthia's Attic. I even
thought it was the best book I have ever
heard. I thought it
was sad when they heard Louis had died. -from Shelby
*I really liked the story, but my favorite
part is when Gus tried to pick up the
apple and the lady screamed. And
when Aunt Belle was telling the stories. But I'm just like Cynthia, a girly girl. -Charmain
*I liked the whole book. But my
favorite parts are when Cynthia pushed
Andre off the boat, my other favorite
part is when Gus said it would have
been funny if she hit the waitress
in the head with an apple. Those two
were my favorite parts in the
book. My dad said he's going to buy me all
the Cynthia's Attic. I
hope it's the best like the first one. -from Tattyanna
*I like the part when Gus and Cynthia are
ghosts. What will the next story
title be? -Dudley
Thank
you for your time! Your book was the
highlight of many days for a couple weeks. We
all look
forward to the next one in the series.
Julie Craig