All of Rosenthal's piano rolls - with the exception of the "Harmonious Blacksmith" - were reissued on LP on L'Oiseau-Lyre 414 098-1. It's probable that most of them have been reissued on CD as well. Most of the information below comes from Larry Sitsky's "The Classical Reproducing Piano Roll," published by Greenwood Press, and is used with Professor Sitsky's permission.
The date format for issue is year/month. This gives only a general idea of the recording date, however, since it was not that unusual for years to elapse between the initial recording of the roll and its issue.
| Composer | Piece | Catalogue # | Pub. date |
| Albeniz | Cantos de Espana, Op. 232, #2: Orientale | 69701H | 1929/03 |
| Bortkiewicz | Etude, Op. 15 #8 | 67133H | 1927/02 |
| Chopin | Etude, Op. 25 #06 (Thirds) | 62961H | 1924/04 |
| Chopin | Waltz #05, Op. 42 | 64123H | 1925/03 |
| Chopin - Liszt | Chants polonaises, S. 480, #5: "My Joys" | 66603H | 1926/10 |
| Handel | "The Harmonious Blacksmith," HWV 430, #4 | 71673 | 1931? |
| Mendelssohn | Lieder ohne Worte, Book 1, Op. 19, #1 | 67771H | 1927/07 |
| Mendelssohn | Lieder ohne Worte, Book 5, Op. 62, #6: Spring Song | 67431H | 1927/04 |
| Rosenthal | Papillons | 63831H | 1924/12 |
| Rosenthal | Prelude | 64551H | 1925/05 |
| Rubinstein | Valse Caprice | 70553 | 1930/03 |
| Strauss, J - Rosenthal | Carneval de Vienne | 65313H | 1925/12 |