Lauderdale-by-the-Sea Tax Facts
The Great South-Beach/North-Beach Civic Association Scam
Home | Huge Tax Increase | Fire Assessment | Storm-Water Fee | The Great SBCA/NBCA Scams | Contact Us
Summary of the Great SBCA/NBCA Scams
South Beach Civic Association Registered as a Political Committee

The South Beach Civic Association (SBCA) was registered as a Political Committee with the Broward County Supervisor of Elections from 1999 until April 2004, when it transferred that registration to Lauderdale-by-the-Sea.

Supervisor of Elections Welcomes Clark's SBCA Political Committee

Broward County Registered Political Committees

The "Agreement" with the South Beach Civic Association:

Over the years there has been much talk about the "Agreement" approved by the LBTS Town Commission on August 8, 2000, without any prior circulation to citizens of the Town or public hearings.  The Agreement has often been cited as a commitment by the Town to fund sewer and storm-drain construction in the old Intra-coastal/Beach Area, but few in the north or the south have ever read the agreement.

In fact, the document specifies that it is only valid "consistent with [the Town's] legal authority" to enter into agreements.  (No Commission has legal authority to commit future commissions to specific financial actions.)

Moreover, it is clear that only the "excess revenues generated by the Town from real and personal property located within the Intra-coastal/Beach Area" are to be dedicated to capital improvements in that area.  Also, each year the Town's proposed budget for such expenditures is to include those "anticipated excess revenues."  All that is clearly spelled out in paragraph 7 of the Agreement, which may be read by clicking on the link below.  But we were told by the previous Town Manager that such estimates were not being prepared, at the specific request of the South Beach Civic Association (SBCA) Board of Directors.  Baldwin added that he even doubted there WAS any actual surplus at that point in time.

SBCA-Town Commission Agreement, August 8, 2000

Whatever the limitation on the commitments within the four corners of the 2000 "Agreement," many residents of the old Intracoastal/Beach Area allege that they were "promised" sewers and (Terra Mar Island only) storm drains at Town expense following annexation.  Whether they were ever told that by Town officials, or whether their belief is based solely on statements by the SBCA (now doing business as North Beach Civic Association -- NBCA) is not clear. 

Nor is it clear whether or not there may have been back-room deals not fully codified in the 2000 "Agreement."  It IS clear, however, that the Mayor and old-guard commissioners have invariably voted for sewers (even in two private communities: the Palm Club and Sunset Lane), storm drains, and all other capital improvements demanded by the S/NBCA, without any reference to the magnitude -- or even the existence -- of a "surplus" generated from that area.  Chuck Clark (not then yet a commissioner) boasted to a November 2003 closed meeting of his S/NBCA Executive Committee that "out of the $40 million [in the Town's budget] for capital improvements, $12 million is for the south and the rest [$28 million] for us."

It is also clear that the S/NBCA has supported the Mayor and old-guard commissioners, Yanni and Wessels, against challengers in the elections held since annexation.  A February 2004 campaign letter from former SBCA President Jack Cooney urged north-beach voters to vote for Clark and Yanni in the March 2004 municipal elections. 

Nobember 2003 S/NBCA BOD Meeting Minutes

S/NBCA PAC February 2004 Campaign Letter

Our exposés of the great South Beach Civic Association (SBCA) BOD Scam began by explaining how a tiny group of politicians, developers, and ambitious beach-front property owners had set up a non-representative corporation with only six voting members, elected a secretive pro-developer board of directors who passed themselves off as representing residents of the whole “Intracoastal/ /beach area” and struck a “sweetheart” deal with the mayor and other members of the old LBTS Town Commission.  That deal furthered their own pro-developer and anti-height-limit agenda at the expense of a majority of residents of old-town LBTS and of the annexed area. 

Part II showed how that same SBCA BOD crew insisted, for the annexed area, on continued county fire support they assured us the property owners of that area would “happily” pay for (never intending that would actually happen).  It tells how - under the leadership of their anointed commissioners Kennedy and Clark, and with the full complicity of former BSO official Bob Baldwin and Ken Jenne’s new-found buddy Oliver Parker (who swore in 2000, “Over my dead body do I want Sheriff Jenne to come in and take over our Police & Fire Departments!”) – they made county fire suppression in the north the “tail that wagged the dog” resulting in the imposition of BSO fire service also on the totally unwilling residents of old-town LBTS and, in November 2006, in the arbitrary termination of the LBTS Volunteer Fire Department (VFD) on trumped-up, unsubstantiated, even unevaluated charges, without EITHER the popular referendum OR the fair, impartial evaluation of the VFD’s ability to provide  safe, highly cost-effective fire service to the entire Town, BOTH OF WHICH voters had been promised along the way by Parker and his old-guard buddies as sops to quiet the public, never intending to implement either of those fiducially responsible, democratic procedures. 

A proposed final Installment of our exposé of the “Great SBCA BOD Scam” would consider the genesis of the SBCA BOD’s annexation demands, the “deal” former SBCA President Chuck Clark said was cut to appeal both to single-family homeowners and to condo dwellers in the north, what the MAIN objective of the pre-annexation demands probably was, and why LBTS old-guard commissioners went along initially – and are still going along today!  Hint:  In every municipal election since annexation the SBCA BOD has supported Mayor Parker and incumbent commissioners, while the Mayor and the incumbent old-guard commissioners have routinely voted for Town funding of all capital improvements the SBCA/NBCA has asked for.

Click on the links below to read each of the three exposés of the S/NBCA.

  

S/NBCA Scam, Part 1

S/NBCA Scam, Part 2

S/NBCA Scam, Part 3

Recent "Reality Checks"  The S/NBCA continues to try to deceive LBTS citizens -- including those north-beach residents it claims to represent -- as to its basic political nature.  In April 2007 the copy-cat, pro-developer, pro-BSO publication that serves as the S/NBCA’s propaganda organ, with current S/NBCA President Mark Brown on its editorial board, issued a so-called “reality check” of the above exposés.  Click on the link below to have a look!

Deceitful S/NBCA "Reality Check"

In its next two issues, By-the-Sea Times published a number of official documents that establish beyond the shadow of a doubt the political history of the S/NBCA and the illegal laundering of political contributions through which they apparently sought to disguise the extent of their political activity in the run-up to the 2004 municipal elections.  (Click on the links below.)  In the face of such incontrovertible evidence, Brown and his S/NBCA cronies must really think their LBTS neighbors to be extremely naive and gullible if they expect them to be influenced by writings such as that deceitful "reality check!"

Which Paper Can You Believe? ("Reality Check" Debunked)

S/NBCA "Launders" its Political Contributions

This website is committed to factual accuracy and objectivity. Visitors to the site are
        encouraged to report any perceived inaccuracies to us at lbts-tax-facts@earthlink.net.

Visit or return to CIC Website