...Mr. Ford was a true believer in the benefits and power of music and old-fashioned dancing. In starting the old-fashioned dancing program, he,
along with Mr. Lovett, saved a part of the American heritage for the present generation and those to follow.
To know his crusade to bring back old-fashioned dancing had been so successful and enduring would please Mr. Ford. He, however, never believed the
old-fashioned dances had ever left. When someone commented about his bringing back the old dances, he said, 'They've always been here.'
...The Early American dancers of today owe Mr. Ford and Mr. and Mrs. Lovett a great sense of gratitude. It is because of their unique partnership, the
Lovetts' talent and diligence, and Mr. Ford's great interest in old-fashioned dancing, that many people still merrily swing to an allemande left and an
allemande right. Early American dancing is not a relic from a crowded attic of nostalgia, but is still a part of the recreational scene. While watching a
recent ...Early American dance program, at beautiful Lovett Hall and seeing the joyful, rhythmical dancers, it was evident old-time dancing is very much
alive. You need not be concerned about old-fashioned dancing being asleep, Mr. Ford and Mr. Lovett. It is still 'good morning' with the Early American
dances."
What Would Henry Think?
Everyone knows about his automobiles, but Henry Ford had another love: traditional, historic American dance. In fact, Henry arranged for a
beautiful ballroom to be created just for traditional dance - square dances, New England contras, Appalachian Big Circle Dances, and more - right here in
Michigan, at his famous Greenfield Village, now called The Henry Ford. He even hired a New England dancing master, Benjamin Lovett, and named his
elegant dance hall forhim: Lovett Hall.
Lovett Hall is still there, still in beautiful condition. And traditional dances, open to the public and featuring renowned dance caller Glen Morningstar and
the live music of the amazing Ruffwater Stringband, are still going on - for a little while. For the management of The Henry Ford has decided to turn over
Lovett Hall to its catering division. And since big events with catered foods pay better than traditional dances, a new policy has been established which
will severely limit dancers and dance organizers of modest means from continuing to use Lovett Hall as they have for over 23 years.
The museum's new policy requires that at least $4,000 worth of catered food be ordered for any use of Lovett Hall. That's in addition to a rental fee
of several hundred dollars. Refreshments generally offered at contra dances are more likely to be homemade cookies and lemonade, provided by
volunteer dancers, but the THF wants $4,000 to be spent on catered meals, or the hall cannot be rented.
So the dancers are in mourning for the potential loss of their beautiful dance hall. They are hoping that the management will see reason, and understand
that hosting traditional dance is why Lovett Hall was built. They hope that their long history - over 23 years - of keeping alive the spirit of Henry Ford will
be recognized. Henry Ford was a dancer, not a caterer.
What would Henry think?
Best wishes,
Susan Booker, Lexington, KY
What it means to us Messages
about the dance
"Thinking is the hardest work there is, which is the probable reason so few engage in it." --Henry Ford
As you probably are able to guess from last Lovett, the loss affects me very deeply. I had a grand farewell speech to the dancers partly written. I'd planned to
thank you all - the dance community - for sharing the honor of carrying on Ford's dream and legacy. I've always realized the importance of carrying on the
dance, but never thought of it in the light of actually "being living history" until one of the dancers described us in that light.
I began to look at Lovett as a living circle from Ford's time to present, with Glen and Judi picking up the past, carrying it on to present, and ... hopefully, on
into the future. I have been honored to be a part of such a rich tradition. I hope that the circle can come to a gracious and appropriate closing, in its proper
time instead of an ending that is premature.
I don't know if you - the dance community - realize how important, how necessary you are to all of us in the band. I appreciate your participation - your familiar
faces, your smiles, your acknowledgements are always noted! I appreciate your energy, your joy of the dance. There isn't another more beautiful sight than to
see you all enthusiastically enjoying the movements of the dance, in that lovely ballroom built for just such a purpose, giving us back in full measure the energy
we've expended to add lift to it. I thank you for all your kind words about the calling and the music of our Lovett Sundays, for without them we couldn't bring the
joy we have in sharing Lovett Sunday afternoons.
It is my sincere hope that Ford's wish to educate and illuminate others - in the special and unique way of our Lovett dances - is honored by those who are in the
position to further those ideals.
Sincerely, Sharon Robinson |
Alice Hays photo
Sharon plays dulcimer in Ruffwater. I asked permission to use her words, and she replied:
If there was anything contained within my message that you think will further the cause, be my guest. Sometimes when I'm writing straight from the hip and heart,
I'm not sure if it is making the statement I want it to. I do wish a more public forum to thank you all, but doubt I'd ever be able to.
The emotion of last Lovett really blindsided me. I didn't expect to start choking before the last dance.
You all have lit up memories as beautiful as the hall's chandeliers, and for that I sincerely thank you - Sharon
|
|
I am really pleased to note that you are in positive touch with the Dearborn and Lovett Hall powers that be. Your dance program is just
too fine to be superseded by mere food. To me it says volumes that Lovett Hall exists to exemplify the wholesome and beautiful forms of dance that meant so
much to the first Henry Ford.
I am sure that there will be a spontaneous crowd of people at the dance in February. We honor you for your fine band and excellent dance program, and we
expect to see the program continued indefinitely, especially when there is this positive and favorable response.
Sincerely, Sylvia Lewis, Ann Arbor
When the Lovett Hall dance series disappears, all of us in the dance community will lose something special, not just the Michigan dancers. On Friday evening,
I'll make an announcement during the Los Angeles New Year's Eve contra ball (and will bring supporting printouts from Karen's website), and will encourage
the dancers to sign a "thank-you" letter to The Henry Ford from the L.A. dance community. Others of you calling or attending New Year's Eve dances in other
communities might consider something similar -- let's let The Henry Ford know that we all recognize the importance of the Lovett Hall dance.
...At the Los Angeles New Year's Eve dance, when I started my announcement about Lovett Hall, two dozen dancers cheered when they heard the name
"Lovett Hall." And then all 130 dancers booed when they heard the rest of my announcement.
Jeremy Korr, Rancho Cucamonga, CA
 |
Dear friends,
I am writing to urge you to reverse your decision to end contradancing in Lovett
Hall.
I have never danced there, and probably I never will. I am a member of the Toronto Country Dancers, who dance in church gyms. They are fine ... but if we
had a venue like Lovett Hall, we would move heaven and earth to keep it.
Contradancing can be done by young (I've seen parents dancing with toddlers on their hips) and old, by good dancers and by people like me who are
balletically challenged. Perhaps that is part of what attracted Henry Ford to it.
I understand that you want to use Lovett Hall for events that bring in more money than contradancing. Forgive me for thinking that opportunity cost - foregone
profit - is not the same thing as actually losing money, and that the Founder's wishes ought to count for something. Indeed, the fact that Henry Ford
supported contradancing seems to me to cover a multitude of his sins.
|
Someone - John Kenneth Galbraith? - used the phrase "private affluence and public squalor" to describe Detroit. This semi-public use of the splendor of
Lovett Hall seems to me to be a welcome exception to that characterization, and something that ought not to be thrown by the wayside.
Please think again.
Yours sincerely,
Elizabeth Block, Toronto, Ontario
I'm writing out of concern that a decision has apparently been made which would mean that Lovett Hall could no longer be used for regularly-scheduled
traditional contra and square dances.
I am a dancer, a dance caller, a dance historian and a dance videographer. My dance documentaries have aired on public television and as part of the 2004
Dance on Camera Festival in New York City. I have never had the opportunity to dance in Lovett Hall, yet from a distance I know of its importance in American
social dance history and I cherish dreams of one day being able to dance there.
The mission of The Henry Ford is well stated:
"The Henry Ford provides unique educational experiences based on authentic objects, stories, and lives from America's traditions of ingenuity, resourcefulness
and innovation. Our purpose is to inspire people to learn from these traditions to help shape a better future."
As you certainly know, Henry Ford himself was deeply involved in an effort to help people learn from American traditional music and dance. Ford built Lovett Hall
as a venue in which this kind of dancing could be practiced, and Benjamin Lovett himself was recruited by Ford to assist in the effort to bring back the old forms
of dance. My copy of Good Morning is the 1926 edition, in which we read the following:
"With characteristic American judgment, however, the balance is now shifting toward that style of dancing which best fits with the American temperament.
There is a revival of that type of dancing which has survived longest amongst the northern peoples. The tide has swing in favor of such dances as are described in
this book."
One might add, "and as have been danced at Lovett Hall in recent decades."
|
"The Lighted Sconce" gets rolling... Stu Brown photo.
|
It would be ironic indeed if The Henry Ford closed for regular dances one spectacular hall built by Henry Ford himself for that explicit purpose. I hope you
are able to reconsider this decision and allow the regular contra and square dances to continue in their rightful home.
Yours truly,
David Millstone, Lebanon, NH
...and the band awaits a down-beat. Stu Brown photo.
| |
At the Peninsula Dance Thursday, Ranger Rebecca Jones, as part of her Contra Conversation series, spoke on the history of Lovett Hall.
This was not the first time. Henry Ford’s building of this hall for contra dancing by dance master Benjamin Lovett has been mentioned in several others of her
talks. She chose this topic because The Henry Ford (a.k.a. Greenfield Village) has cancelled this series. The February 6th dance is the last dance for the
foreseeable future.
Since it is inappropriate for a government employee to do so, Rebecca restrained from offering a personal opinion about this action, but rather kept to
the facts. As you shall soon read, I’m under no such restriction.
First let me say that I have but once been to this dance. I had tried to get a group together but, failing that, went alone. It was truly a memorable affair.
If you have not been there, try to make it to the February dance (if you have been there, I’m sure you will want to go again). Steve Suvar is willing to help
organize a group for this last dance. You may wish to travel with them.
Dances come and go but this case is different. This isn’t a church hall used for a dance, or a multi-purpose room used for a dance; it’s a DANCE
HALL! And it isn’t JUST a dance hall, it’s a Contra Dance hall, built exactly for that purpose and in support of Henry Ford’s wish to revive group dancing.
HF hired Benjamin Lovett and built Lovett Hall to accommodate this.
I wrote THF myself and got the form letter response
from Christian Overland. Among other items he states that “attendance for our dancing classes has dwindled in the last few years” and also “The Henry Ford
must respond rationally to current market needs and interests…”.
Try if you wish, THF, I mean it is your place, but Six Flags you ain’t! You’re a museum, for heaven sakes. If the dance were being forced out by a need for more
space for antique cars, this might be justifiable, but we are seemingly being displaced by wedding receptions. These, while doubtlessly nice, have nothing to do
with a museum’s mission.
|
The letter ends with “I would like to extend the opportunity for this group of contra dancers (like other organizations we host) to rent our
facilities.” Local dancers made inquiries, and found not only that the posted $600 rental was $800 but has attached to it a minimum $4,000 catering bill, whether
we need catering or not. This prices it way outside our capability. I have difficulty believing that the seven dances per year that they have been hosting have
significant impact on their balance sheet.
Mr. Overland also wrote, “Decisions like this do not come easily; we understand and appreciate the disappointment they are likely to generate.”
Frankly, sir, I think you are wrong on both counts. Boards I’ve encountered facing similar situations open a dialog with the problem tenant to see if there is a win-win
possibility; e.g., higher admission, fewer dances presumably attracting larger crowds, better marketing, etc. THF took no such action, canceling this year with no
warning even after the schedule had been published by them. Further, I don’t think that the Board as non-dance-gypsies could possibly understand the
Jerusalem-like status of Lovett Hall.
This is where YOU can come in! Write Mr. Overland and tell him. Thank THF for the many years of dances there (24 under Glen Morningstar, caller). And
ask if there is not some way this series can continue.
Another sympathetic ear might be Henry’s great-grandson and THF board member, Bill Ford:
William C. Ford, Jr., Chairman
Ford Motor Company
16800 Executive Plaza Dr., PO Box 6248
Dearborn, MI 48121
And you can read about this in the Yahoo group.
Diatribe over, Bob McKimm
|
 |
The reason [the management team] is mentioned so much by us is that THEY were the ones who contacted Glen and said (with a mere 4 days notice)
that the dance was being cancelled. The Board, who according to these form letters were the ones to make the decision, didn't even have the decency
to contact Glen themselves.
Attention to "fit with our educational mission" seems ludicrous to those of us who feel we are nearly the definition of that mission - historic, educational,
etc. Not to mention the ONLY fit with the purposes behind that particular building. And if "dwindling attendance" was putting a financial strain on the
Museum's budget, why couldn't they have ever even mentioned that to Glen? We dancers could have figured out how to increase attendance; we would
probably have paid more for the dance; we could have looked for grants to help continue it.
Glen offered them several options; they never even discussed why they turned them down.
I have to say this, knowing that Glen won't ever - the way this was done was one of the most disrespectful things I've ever seen, and
neither Glen nor the band nor the dancers deserve it.
Noemi Ybarra, Lafayette, Ind.
 |
I just got around to joining trad-dance-callers, and saw your recent message. I'm very sorry to hear about the untimely termination of the Lovett Hall
dance series. I'd heard over the years that Henry Ford enjoyed square dances, and that he'd built a hall. I hadn't actually known that dancers were presently being
held in the hall, let alone that a regular contra series existed. It sounds now like I'll miss the opportunity of ever dancing in Lovett Hall. If I still lived in Texas, I'd think
of trying to make the dance next weekend. However, I moved out here to Oregon in the summer of 2001, and have a commitment next weekend (attending
Dancing Fool in Seattle).
I vaguely recall from our conversations in Austin, Texas years ago (when you would head down for the Kerrville Easter Hill Country Tour with Pedal phernalia) that
you enjoyed a dance "in the village" near where you lived. Forgive me if I missed the significance of that statement. I'll mention the dance next weekend to folks
out here, but given the distance and the short time until the dance, I suspect you won't see any of us there. Have a great dance in our absence!
William Watson, Corvallis, OR
|
Thanks for all you've done to help preserve the American Contra Dance Series at Lovett Hall. .... It was an afternoon to remember! It's great that you are continuing
to prod the powers-that-be to keep this series going. I'm afraid that THF, like many museums, has taken the position that they need to run their facility on a
"business model," and that means that ultimately the issue is money. While I understand THF's desire and probable need to increase revenue, I fear that the real
reason for the very precipitous demise of the contra dance series is an effort to "clear the boards" of small 'outside' groups who could interfere with more
grandiose corporate designs.
I and my Columbus friends have only had the opportunity to come up for a handful of dances over the years. It's not the monthly dances we will miss but the
opportunity for the "special trip." There may be a natural cycle to dance series, and as Glen said, traditional dancing will, we hope, one day return to Lovett. But
only if there still is the Lovett Hall that we know. I think I most fear that the lack of the dance series will provide no impetus to THF to preserve the facility and it may
go the way of many of the fine dance floors in this country. Many, if not most, of the continuing users of the facility will not appreciate that WONDERFUL FLOOR.
I would ask you all, "the local guardians" of Lovett to continually update the rest of us to the situation, and encourage us to petition THF for the return of
traditional dancing to Lovett. That effort won't be won in a day.
|
Your web goddess at the last dance. (I have wanted a Lovett Hall T-shirt for some 20 years, and finally decided to make my own.)
Jerry Hickman photo.
|
Most of all, I would also ask you to keep in front of THF and the local public the most unique and valuable historical and cultural resource which they have named
in honor of Benjamin Lovett, so that it remains what it was meant to be. If that can happen, then when the day Glen prophesized comes, Mr. Lovett's Hall will be
ready for our return. I am certainly planning on being there for the Seventieth Anniversary dance!
Thanks again and hope to meet you soon coming down the set.
Michael Darby, Columbus, OH
Comments about the article in the Detroit News
I am one of the many dancers saddened by the sudden cancellation of the contra dances held for 23 years at Lovett Hall and led by Glen Morningstar.
Your article conveys the great sense of loss that it brings to all the dancers and musicians who have treasured the tradition and history of this fine place, feeling
directly connected to Henry Ford's era. The magic and charm of the Lovett Hall ballroom filled with the joy of movement, music, friendship and song was an
uplifting and energizing experience. I hope The Henry Ford will work to make that happen again in the future.
Mary H. Bandyke, Dearborn
Thank you so much for your fine article on the "last dance" at Lovett Hall. There is no finer place to dance in this country and it's an opportunity to gain an
understanding of the evolution of contra dancing.
Hopefully The Henry Ford will reverse its decision and the hall will again vibrate with the sounds of contra dancing and the joy of many hearts dancing.
Sincerely, Diane Seaman, Detroit
Lovely story. It was a great dance, but a very sad day. It's hard to believe that "The Henry Ford" administration can't manage to make this available once or twice
a year - just to keep the tradition alive. The dancing will continue, but it's the end of one era for Greeenfield Village.
Carol Fowler, Jackson
A message posted on our Yahoo group in October 2005..."high school dances have changed..."
Last night my soon-to-be 15-year-old daughter went to her first high school dance. My wife and I were chaperones, along with 15 other parents.
It was a Halloween dance. High school dances have changed in the last 5 years. Police were on hand, along with the principal, to approve costumes.
Most of them were on the slutty side for the girls, any without underwear were told to wear some or be refused. Undulating to throbbing rock music, with
300-400 dancers gathered tightly in a mass in the middle of the dance floor, it was a touchy-feely free for all with my time spent breaking up couples who
were dry humping too much on the perimeter. In the center, 10 feet away, couples were doing a lot more, and occasional forays through to the center
would restore clothing and order.
50 or so students were having fun doing normal dancing. They were the outsiders, geeks and band members, not part of the 'in' crowd.
Other parents said the shift to this so-called dancing came 4-5 years ago partly as a result of what they see on TV.
My daughter asked to be taken home. On the drive home, she remarked how much fun it was when we danced at Lovett Hall in 2003, her first real
dancing experience, and how disappointed she was in what passes for dancing in high school today. She was expecting waltzs, swings and twirls. I
checked on doing Lovett Hall once again, and found this site. Sad news.
I plan on writing Dick Kughn, a THF director and antique car friend, and see if he can do something to bring Lovett Hall back. We need THF to provide
some sort of dance outlet that is fun for kids and young adults, and parents, not the trash that passes for dancing like last night. HFC has the opportunity
to educate a new generation of young adults to more retro style dancing, Sounds like Contra dancing to me.
Cheers, Lee Jacobsen, Dearborn, MI
A message posted on our Yahoo group August 2007..."scratches and scuffs..."
After attending a large (non-dance related) convention in Detroit a couple of weeks ago, I decided to stick around an extra day and visit the
Henry Ford Museum, Greenfield Village, and Lovett Hall. Although I'd never been there previously as I live several hundred miles away, I'd
read and heard about all three for a long time and was well-aware of the shameful treatment the dance community - and Lovett Hall -
have received recently.
I found the first two with no difficulty, and enjoyed my visit (although comparisons with Disneyland's Main Street USA were inevitable),
and I found the scatter-shot arrangement of artifacts at the Henry Ford a bit disconcerting. I also felt that the place was designed to
confirm what most Americans with common knowledge of history and material culture already know and feel, rather than to expand such
knowledge, or to increase curiousity about less-familiar, perhaps less comfortable aspects of history. But there may well be good reasons
for the populist and comfortably unchallenging approach, and certainly Henry Ford's character was reflected throughout both the museum
and village. So I took what I could from both places, and enjoyed the rather sanitized version of history they presented.
But I had to inquire about Lovett Hall's whereabouts. It was hiding in plain sight, behind a padlocked gate next to the Henry Ford. I had
to re-enter the museum and exit by a little-used side door to access Lovett Hall.
Once there, I found the front door unlocked, and no one inside. I made my way up the staircase, and gasped at the beautiful ballroom,
whose crystal chandeliers and antique furnishings remain in place. I began to softly whistle English country dance music - and then danced
a little solo dance, with an invisible partner and corners. It was a thrill just to be in such a historic place, and to know Lovett Hall's history.
Then I looked around a little more closely. The room was set up for a reception, with many large round tables covered in white
tablecloths. Chairs were not yet in place, however, nor were there any decorations. There was an open area in the midst of the room, right
in front of the musicians' gallery - presumably for dancing at what was probably going to be a wedding reception that evening (my
guess was correct - I later saw the bridesmaids, in stiletto heels).
Then I looked at that wonderful polished wooden floor, which the Henry Ford management claimed had to be rewaxed regularly to
accommodate the dancers.
It bore many long scratches leading to the legs of those round tables. Not just scuffs. Scratches, up to six feet in length. While the
floor was clean, the scratches were all over the place. I looked more closely - and saw many small indentions, no doubt from spike heels.
So much for preserving tangible history.
Above the staircase's landing hangs a tribute to Henry Ford and Benjamin Lovett, with a poorly-lit explanation about the origins,
history, and raison-d'etre of Lovett Hall. It makes no mention of the long series of dances held there by the Morningstars...or that
Lovett Hall is now in the hands of the caterers. I photographed it, but doubt that many non-dancer visitors to the ballroom even notice the
tribute, tucked away as it is.
Later, near Greenfield Village's Main Street area I was pleased to see a group of dancers clad in 1904 styles and doing the "animal
dances" of that era - the Turkey Trot, Bunny Hug, Grizzly Bear, etc. Their spokeswoman was quite effective, and they were drawing
members of the audience to dance with them (to recorded ragtime music). I complimented a few of them on their performance, and
asked about what vintage dance group this might be.
I was told that they were all Henry Ford employees, and that they'd recently had four weeks of lessons in vintage dance.
I was glad to hear this - but upon later slightly cynical reflection, realized that while these dancers' performance was very entertaining,
appropriate, and a welcome addition to Greenfield Village's activities, their performances also allow the HF management to clain that they
are preserving traditional dance, and inviting the public to join right in.
Very educational, no doubt. And there's not one in a thousand visitors who would see any dark side to it at all - but I was that one.
Not quite the same, is it?
I am not sure my swipes at The Henry Ford's presentation and apparent philosophy (which gives the impression of a very idealized,
somewhat Norman Rockwell-ish view of American history) are actually relevant, but they do sort of fit in with my take on seeing the
vintage dances performed by employees. I surmized that the HF management could thus claim that they were continuing to feature and
support dance - I don't know that they've actually made this claim. And in a way, of course they ARE featuring dance - it was just that this
was clearly performance dance, not the open-to-the-public dances the Morningstars produced for so many years.
The damage to the surface of the Lovett Hall floor was very dismaying, though otherwise the room appeared adequately cared-for. Again,
the condition of the floor was something a dancer would notice more than the casual observer/visitor.
It seems to me that the catering department, or whoever they hire to move their tables and chairs around, should be told to lift, not drag,
to avoid scarring the floor. Six-foot long scars were most noticeable, and deplorable on any dance floor - but on THIS particular dance
floor, they seemed to illustrate either an ignorance of Lovett Hall's raison d'etre and history, or a lack of respect and appreciation
for that history. In either case, they show someone's carelessness and willingness to do things the easy way, rather than the right way.
Sadly, Susan Booker, Lexington, KY
|
|