I listened to a lot more "classic rock" today than I normally do. All of the songs I heard today were, of course, familiar to me, and I enjoyed hearing them, but I'm not a fan of the "classic rock" or "golden oldies" radio format. I used to think my distaste for it was that I didn't like the idea of restricting oneself to only the familiar - but that's not it. After all, I spend a lot of time re-listening to my old, familiar CDs. No, what I don't like about "classic rock" radio is that their selection tends to be so
narrow - to me it's like listening to three "Greatest Hits of the 70s" CDs over and over and over, day after day.
With that rant out of my system, I heard
American Pie, by Don McLean, today. That, in my opinion, is a great song. It is a work of poetry. I'm serious - I realize that many people dismiss it because 1) it's been over-played (but not quite too much, thanks to its 9 minute or so length) and 2) so many people have discussed its meaning (look it up on the internet - there are scores of web sites out there). It is precisely that second reason that makes it such a masterpiece. Like the best Bob Dylan songs, the overall meaning is understood, but analyzing individual lines provokes discussion, thought, trivia, and debate.
(It's accepted that the song itself is a history of rock-and-roll, which McLean felt had declined after "The day the music died" - which most people seem to feel was the day the plane crash killed Buddy Holly, Richie Valens, and The Big Bopper. Much debate centers around who or what is or was "Miss American Pie," however.)
("The jester sang for the king and queen / In a coat he borrowed from James Dean / In a voice that came from you and me" From other parts of the song, it's clear that the jester is Bob Dylan, whose roots were in folk music, and who became the voice of a generation, and who posed for the cover of
The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan in a red jacket similar to the one James Dean wore in
Rebel Without A Cause, but who are the king and queen? Are they John and Jackie Kennedy? Or is it a reference to the time Dylan played for Queen Elizabeth and was criticized for not dressing properly?)
Besides all that, it's hard to imagine any 9 minute rock song becoming a #1 radio hit these days. Rap, maybe, Techno, maybe, but not a rock song.