Demand for medical services in remote areas and staffing shortages push radiology to the ends of the earth
By Douglas Page
A year ago, surgeons at Massachusetts General Hospital, guided by digital x-rays transmitted from the South
Pole, helped a physician at the Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station surgically repair the damaged knee of a meteorologist overwintering
in Antarctica. Teleradiology plays a leading role in such long-distance medical dramas. Three other Antarctic research stations
are now wired to transfer DICOM (Digital Imaging and Communication in Medicine) images directly to the University of Texas
Medical Branch at Galveston (UTMB).
Although research stations are staffed by emergency physicians and physician assistants,
onsite specialty care is limited. UTMB's role is to provide a specialty opinion in difficult cases. Providing polar teleradiology
presents unique challenges, however. The South Pole is 17 hours ahead of Central Standard Time, and satellite line-of-sight
variability makes communications acceptable for irregular periods only.
"Some days they may have a large-bandwidth
pipe over which to communicate, and other times it's minimal at best," said Jake Angelo, director of technology at UTMB's
Center for Telehealth and Distance Education. "In order to hit a satellite you have to shoot over the equator, and the Earth
gets in the way if you're on the South Pole."
The Antarctic incident is an example of how contempory radiology is
being recast to meet changing radiology demands. Reshaped by digital technologies, demand for remote medical services, and
personnel shortages, today's radiology department is no longer a medical monolith confined to the hospital basement.
may still find imaging modalities at the end of locator lines painted on hospital corridor walls, but the reading radiologists
themselves are now often found across town or even on the other side of the world. It is not unusual for the midnight scans
of a car accident victim in Minnesota to be read within three minutes by a radiologist in Bangalore, India.
defined, teleradiology is a means of electronically transmitting radiographic patient images and consultative text from one
location to another. Image transmission depends primarily on high-speed electronic communication pipelines such as ATM (asynchronous
transfer mode) or gigabit networks that enable rapid transmission of digital images without loss of content or resolution.
Advances in computer technology, telecommunications, and digital medicine have served mostly to widen the digital
divide between the developed and the developing worlds. Those who need technology the most have the least. In sub-Saharan
Africa, 14 entire countries do not have a single radiologist. But teleradiology is adept at closing economic and technological
gaps. The critical infrastructure necessary to support double-reads or electronic consultations in emergency or special cases
is slowly threading its way into the Third World. High-speed data links to the African continent are coming online via an
undersea cable launched last year, signaling good news for patients in areas with few medical services.
The $650 million
cable backbone, built by a consortium of 36 telecommunication companies led by Telkom, stretches from Portugal, down the west
coast of Africa, around the Cape of Good Hope, and on to India and Malaysia, delivering up to 130 Gbps. All countries along
Africa's Atlantic coast have immediate access. Links to landlocked nations will follow as necessary.
services are, in fact, popping up all around the world:
- Colombia: The Centro de Telemedicina network
connects two islands in the Caribbean, Leticia and Centro Providencia in the Amazon, and an aboriginal community between the
Apaporis and Miriti rivers to a central server and diagnostic workstations in Bogota.
- Tomsk, Russia:
The Telemedicine Center at Siberian State Medical University is gearing up to support 12 medical disciplines at university
clinics, including teleradiology.
"We are ready to transmit radiological images in order to create faster diagnosis,"
said Khasanshin Yuri, chief of information technology.
- South Africa: The Eastern Cape TeleHealth
Programme supports diagnostic services in hospitals in rural areas of the Eastern Cape province. Candidate teleradiology images
for consult are sent from these hospitals to the Basel University iPath server.
- Nigeria: The Jajuwa
Foundation supports a store-and-forward teleradiology service, using a digital camera to snap x-ray films to forward by e-mail.
- Punjab, India: The Development of Telemedicine Technology links three major North India hospitals
practicing teleradiology, telecardiology, and telepathology.
- Islamabad, Pakistan: The philanthropic
TelMedPak project is trying to improve health services for rural residents and reduce the isolation of rural practitioners
through the use of telemedicine technologies, including teleradiology. Images are transferred initially using simple e-mail
- Tokelau: On this isolated Pacific atoll with limited medical resources, the Tokelau
Health Telemedical Program provides access to specialist resources in New Zealand, including the ability to transmit images
from a digital camera, scans of x-rays and electrocardiograms, and captured images from the ultrasound scanner.
in the form of satellite-operated telecenters housed in recycled 20-foot metal ISO shipping containers (called LINCOS, for
"little intelligent communities") has begun to address connectivity needs in areas of Togo, Uganda, Tanzania, and Kenya, as
well as parts of the Philippines, Vietnam, Russia, and Brazil.
Long Distance Remedy
Teleradiology in the West, while more mature in Scandanavia and the U.S., is just finding its legs elsewhere,
propelled by the same interests and demands for remote medical services as in the Third World.
In Europe, several
pilot teleradiology programs have been conducted, mostly within hospital groups or academia, to test technical, organizational,
legal, and economic issues in digitization and networking in specific areas, said Dr. Erik Ranschaert, a radiologist at Jeroen
Bosch Ziekenhuis in 's-Hertogenbosch, the Netherlands.
One example is the Rhineland-Palatinate project in Germany,
which makes use of the CHILI network. Another example in Germany is a project in Saxony, called SaxTeleMed, a government initiative
covering seven regional projects and 39 hospitals.
In Italy, a RIS/PACS implementation under way at a provincial level
includes four heterogeneous hospitals and two healthcare centers, representing approximately 290,000 procedures annually.
Also in Italy, the Island Project consists of a cardiological and radiological telemedicine videoteleconsulting network, connecting
the islands of Procida and Ischia off the Naples coast to mainland hospitals of Pozzuoli and Giugliano.
and teleradiology between hospitals is most advanced in Scandinavia, where many hospitals already have PACS, a necessary component.
The Pax Vobiscum project in Sweden built one virtual filmless radiology department through the total digitization and integration
of five independent radiology departments within Orebro County. This virtual department, which performs approximately 180,000
procedures a year, is one of the largest PACS installations in Europe, with 48 radiology rooms forming a functional unit.
"In most other EU countries, PACS is still relatively scarce, and therefore teleradiology is simply not possible,"
In the Netherlands, however, digitization has flourished. Ranschaert estimates that most hospitals
there will have PACS by the end of 2005.
Experts agree that today's radiologist
shortage will only get worse-the workforce is aging and fewer new radiologists are joining its ranks. Teleradiology offers
a likely solution. In some cases, teleradiology is not only bringing medicine to the underserved, it is relieving rural hospitals
of the burden of attracting their own radiologists, which is becoming more difficult.
"Without radiology services,
rural hospitals will tell you they cannot keep their doors open," said Steven Mecklenburg, telehealth coordinator at Poudre
Valley Health System in Fort Collins, CO.
Poudre Valley's telehealth system began in 1998. It provides diagnostic-quality
digital teleradiology to several outlying hospitals in the High Plains region of Colorado and Nebraska, including Haxtun Hospital
District in Haxtun, CO; Memorial Health Center in Sidney, NE; Kimball Community Hospital in Kimball, NE; and Morrill County
Hospital, in Bridgeport, NE.
Teleradiology projects abound throughout the U.S.: The Children's Memorial Medical Center
telemedicine service in Chicago includes clinical consultations and interpretations in cardiology and radiology, connecting
institutional and physician sites in the U.S. and several international sites. In Minnesota, the Allina Health System/Rural
Health Alliance Telemedicine Network links rural locations to urban radiology subspecialists for emergency coverage. The Upper
Peninsula Telehealth Network provides teleradiology coverage throughout northern Michigan.
In Puerto Rico, the Telemedicine
Pilot Study installed a system between the municipality of Vieques and the Tertiary Centro Medico emergency and radiology
department in San Juan that allows patients to have imaging studies performed and diagnosed from Veiques. This saves them
the expense of traveling to the main island.
While the U.S. may have the richest concentration of teleradiology programs,
it also has a full complement of challenges. Among the hazards of providing state-to-state teleradiology is malpractice insurance,
which is not only expensive but difficult to obtain in large part because teleradiology-focused insurance companies are new
and the risks are unclear. The idea of radiologists interpreting images at 3 a.m. from their bedrooms causes insurance company
decision-makers to shudder.
A 2002 report from the Institute of Management and Administration in New York found that
one recent quote was $225,000 per year for covering 90,000 reads, an amount equal to approximately $50,000 per full-time radiologist,
assuming each FTE did 20,000 reads per year. The rates are high, according to the report, because malpractice lawyers can
pick the most plaintiff-friendly states in which to sue. They can file suit in the state where the teleradiology firm is based,
the state where the patient is located, or even in another state where the teleradiology firm happens to do business.
possible to negotiate lower rates ($30,000 to $40,000 per radiologist) if the practice agrees not to read studies from high-liability
areas such as Manhattan and parts of Florida. Licensing is another hurdle. Most states require a full medical license to practice
teleradiology, and this can run as high as $10,000 per state per radiologist, including fees, time, and other costs.
20% shortage of U.S. radiologists is also a trip wire for nighthawk teleradiology services that exploit global time zone variations
for domestic radiology groups.
"The U.S. shortage of radiologists is driving practices to find creative staffing solutions,
including teleradiology, to meet demand for their services," said Dr. David Hirschorn, a clinical fellow in radiology informatics/MRI
at Massachusetts General Hospital.
By stationing or enlisting radiologists in a different time zone to cover nighttime
hours in the U.S., a practice can avoid having any local radiologist take night call, an attractive inducement when recruiting.
Overnight demand for radiologists follows the dramatic increase in emergency department volumes. Taking call most night in
most areas has become untenable.
"Ten years ago I could sleep through the night on call," said Dr. James Sayre, director
of diagnostic radiology at Valley Medical Center in Renton, WA. "Now, they wake us at least once an hour."
cable modems, and virtual private networks are enabling technologies that allow real-time interpretations of nighttime studies
by qualified-and alert-radiologists located thousands of miles away.
nighthawk models have emerged: Radiology groups station one or two of their members overseas for short periods, or they contract
with radiology services already there.
In the Middle East, for instance, two U.S.-trained and board-certified radiologists
living in Israel provide real-time interpretation services during the wee hours in the U.S. for three hospitals in the Crozer-Keystone
Health System in Delaware County, PA. Both radiologists are licensed in Pennsylvania and credentialed at the hospitals they
Between 10 and 30 CTs are transmitted to Israel every night, along with an assortment of ultrasound and nuclear
medicine exams. Head CTs take about two minutes to transmit, and abdominopelvic CTs four to 10 minutes, using compression
settings optimized to increase transmission speed while maintaining diagnostic quality. Network connections are provided over
the Internet by a VPN running over 1.5-Mbps DSL in Israel and a T1 line in the U.S. Workstations are installed in the radiologists'
homes in Israel.
"We take over for the U.S. radiologists between 11 p.m. and 8 a.m.," said Dr. Jonathan Schlakman
of Remote Radiology International. "Head CTs are turned around within five to 10 minutes, and abdominopelvic CTs between 10
and 20 minutes."
Emergency physicians prefer the nighthawk service to the previous night call system, since they now
receive service at night on par with daytime coverage. The hospitals' attitude is so positive that it actually advertises
the service, touting higher quality radiology because scans are being read by a radiologist who is already awake, not by someone
whose sleep has just been disturbed.
While international nighthawk arrangements benefit the practice, the radiologist,
the emergency department, and the patient, controversial issues remain. Reimbursement is one.
"Medicare prevents offshore
final reads from being reimbursed," said Dr. Arjun Kalyanpur, CEO and chief radiologist at Teleradiology Solutions in Bangalore,
Short of sorting all cases immediately based on payer, nighthawks find it simpler to provide preliminary reports,
which the in-house radiology group can scrutinize the next morning before issuing the final report. Next-day review, while
inherently unproductive, is not all bad. It allows the group to perform quality assurance and have the final word on any report,
which is in the best interest of patient care.
Licensing and credentialing can also be issues. In order to provide
international nighthawk services, the interpreting radiologist must be certified by the American Board of Radiology, licensed
in the state in which the image originates, and have malpractice insurance to cover practice within the U.S.
states now offer specific telemedicine licenses that are adequate for teleradiology coverage and somewhat easier to obtain
than the regular state license," Kalyanpur said.
Once the radiologist is licensed in the state in which the group
is located, the only delay is related to credentialing, which can be tedious. A new online physician credentialing service could help. The service, developed by a group of health plans and run by the not-for-profit Council for Affordable
Quality Healthcare, allows physicians to complete a single contract form, which is accepted by all member health plans.
group decided against contracting for nighthawk coverage, choosing instead to rotate one of its own staff eight hours east
of Washington state to a Cambridge, U.K., cottage for several months at a time to provide overnight reads. Sayre himself was
there for six months last year and is returning soon for a two-year stint.
"Unlike other groups that contract out
the service, we recognized that if we signed up with a group that would merely offer preliminary reads, that would allow us
to sleep at night but all that overreading was still to be done the next morning," Sayre said.
The group, which started
its Cambridge teleradiology operation in early 2001, is believed to be the first private group to do so. Because there's not
enough overnight work to keep the Cambridge radiologist occupied full time, the group was taking an economic hit: In addition
to the cost of teleradiology, it was paying full salary for part-time work. The solution was to take late afternoon-early
evening outpatient work in Renton and shift it to England.
Some experts caution those considering nighthawk services
to resist the temptation to dismiss developing nations based on fears of technological inferiority.
to go with a particular nighthawk provider should be determined by performance as certified by current users and by the credentials
of the interpreting radiologists, and not on racial biases or popular conceptions of what may or may not constitute a high-technology
region geographically," Kalyanpur said.
At present, he is the only Indian radiologist providing nighthawk service
to the U.S. He receives an average of 25 emergency scans per day from several U.S. hospitals, including Yale-New Haven Hospital
and the University of Minnesota Clinical Center.
The Cambridge setup is not yet bulletproof. For one thing, weekend
coverage is nonexistent. The radiologist there covers Sunday night through Thursday night back in Renton. Remedies include
a possible contract with a local U.K. group for weekend support.
Teleradiology by Necessity
Japan, local medical law allows any physician to practice radiology. Under Japanese policies, hospitals are equipped with
imaging modalities but are not staffed with radiologists to interpret the studies. Teleradiology has therefore enjoyed a necessary
popularity since 1993.
"Teleradiology offers the possibility to run imaging centers in local communities without radiologists,"
said Dr. Mutsumasa Takahashi, chair of radiology at Kumamoto University School of Medicine.
As elsewhere, Japanese
teleradiology has expanded for other reasons. Information technology has enabled the transmission of high-quality images within
an acceptably short time period. And the introduction of PACS has promoted an acceptance of filmless radiology.
has made significant contributions to Japanese medicine," Takahashi said. "High-quality reports are available to clinicians
quickly for patient management."
Japanese hospitals send imaging exams to one of about 10 radiology groups. Takahashi
directs the largest group, with about 300 hospitals under contract.
"When images are sent to us, we interpret them
within 24 hours, then send the reports to the referring physicians," he said. "We get 600 to 700 studies every day."
group includes 75 to 80 radiologists. It does not currently provide nighthawk services to the U.S., Europe, or elsewhere in
the Pacific, although in the future this is likely.
"The issue is licensing," Takahashi said. "Some countries require
medical licensure in those countries, so it can be rather difficult to establish a teleradiology relationship at present."
Reimbursement is an open issue in Japan as well. Under present Japanese health insurance, fees for MRI interpretation
have been set at x3000 (about US$25) and x2000 (about $16.68) for CT reads.
"This is not adequate for the management
of teleradiology services," Takahashi said.
The reach of teleradiology extends to the high seas, although most experts agree that the maritime teleradiology
is still limited. It does allow the transmission of radiographs from a ship anywhere in the world via satellite and Internet
links for immediate expert radiological opinion and advice.
Among the major cruise lines, only Princess Cruises offers
a teleradiology service. Five of the ships in the Princess fleet beam radiographs back to Southampton University Hospital
in the U.K.
"A number of maritime operators have been offered teleradiology and telemedicine in one form or another,"
said Dr. Vincent Batty, director of nuclear medicine at Southampton. "The biggest stumbling block is cost, particularly since
Cruise lines are enduring faltering tourism, first because of terrorism fears and then because of SARS
and the war in Iraq.
"They're looking to trim expenses. But Princess finds that teleradiology is still worth the expense,"
Teleradiology enables cruise lines to minimize the risk of litigation in the event of medical complications,
and at the same time it allows repudiation of frivolous claims. Maintenance of radiographic equipment aboard ship is another
headache cruise lines don't want.
In the absence of teleradiology, cruise doctors take high-resolution pictures of
x-rays with digital cameras, then e-mail the image to the shoreside consultant. Batty's operation looks at about 20 images
a month from each of the five Princess vessels, mostly plain radiography of chest and extremities.
An American College
of Emergency Physicians report says that 5% of passengers, most of them elderly, experience serious illness during their cruise.
There were 60 deaths on ships sailing out of Miami between 1996 and 1999, according to a 1999 New York Times investigation
of cruise ship medicine. The report also found radical variation in onboard medical standards, including physician competence.
Most cruise ships are registered in countries such as Panama, Liberia, and the Bahamas, which have far less stringent regulations
for physicians than the U.S.
"There is a widely held, naive assumption that medical facilities on a cruise ship are
equivalent to those of a small hospital," Batty said. "This is not the case. A cruise ship may be a floating town, but it
is certainly not a floating hospital."
Batty runs a crew training course to make sure ships' medical personnel are
able to use the imaging equipment properly.
"It's no good just putting the modalities on the ship and asking them
to press a button and send the film over," Batty said. "They've got to be able to send something of good diagnostic value."
Teleradiology liberates the U.S. Air Force
In 1999, the Air Force had 147 radiologists. It expects to have as few as 48 by 2004. The number of military
radiologists is expected to be only 50% of what is needed by this summer. The problem is simple economics: No service branch
can compete with pay structures in civilian practice.
When the radiology department at Travis Air Force Base's David
Grant Medical Center, a tertiary-care 300-bed military teaching hospital, was directed to enlist the services of teleradiology
in 1999, the Air Force quickly ramped up a military network for primary diagnosis. It involved 10 military bases scattered
around the country, from Minot AFB, SD, to Seymour Johnson AFB, NC, and Barksdale AFB, LA.
The network uses the Internet
to transmit images, although every transmission is HIPAA-compliant. A number of challenges surfaced during the big-bang implementation,
including converting some smaller medical facilities to filmless imaging.
Another problem was security, which is complicated
by an ingredient civilian hospitals do not face. Military hospitals are forbidden by the Rules of Armed Conflict to encrypt
any communication originating within their walls, including nonclassified medical data. Encryption of any transmission at
a hospital, even diagnostic images, nullifies the neutral status hospitals enjoy during conflict.
Images moving over
the teleradiology network, therefore, must stop first at the base communications lab, where message encryption occurs before
transmission over the Internet