Outline of Campbell Biology Chapter 9
VII. COMPARISON OF AEROBIC AND ANAEROBIC CATABOLISM
- Introduction
- There are three major catabolic processes for
harvesting food's chemical energy
-
- aerobic respiration
- anaerobic respiration
- fermentation.
- These processes:
- Are similar in that the high energy electrons from
substrate (e.g. glucose) oxidation are transferred to
NAD+.
- Differ in the ultimate fate of high energy electrons
stored in NADH.
- Cellular respiration includes all types of catabolism that use
electron transport chains to make ATP, regardless of the substance
used as the final electron acceptor. It also includes the Krebs
cycle or some modification of the Krebs cycle.
- Aerobic respiration occurs only in the presence of oxygen.
This process:
- Uses an electron transport chain to make ATP.
- Uses oxygen as the final electron acceptor.
- Produces most ATP by oxidative phosphorylation and some ATP
by substrate-level phosphorylation.
- Is used by plants and animals.
- Anaerobic respiration is a catabolic process that does not
require the presence of oxygen. This process:
- Uses an electron transport chain to make ATP.
- Uses a substance other than free oxygen as a final electron
acceptor (e.g. NO3-, SO42-, or
CO32-).
- Produces most ATP by oxidative phosphorylation and some by
substrate-level phosphorylation.
- Occurs in a few bacterial groups that exist in anaerobic
environments.
- Fermentation operates not only without electron transport
chains, but without the Krebs cycle as well.
- No oxygen is required.
- The final electron acceptor is an organic substrate such as
pyruvic acid or some derivative of pyruvic acid.
- ATP is produced by substrate level phosphorylation
only.
- This process is less efficient than respiration.
Respiration yields 18 times more ATP per glucose than
fermentation.
- Organisms can be classified based upon the effect oxygen has
on growth and metabolism.
- Strict (obligate) aerobes = Organisms that require
oxygen for growth and as the final electron acceptor for
aerobic respiration.
- Strict (obligate) anaerobes = Microorganisms that only grow
in the absence of oxygen and are, in fact, poisoned by it.
- Facultative anaerobes = Organisms capable of growth in
either aerobic or anaerobic environments.
- Yeasts, many bacteria and mammalian muscle
cells are facultative anaerobes.
- Some facultative anaerobes make ATP only by fermentation
in the absence of oxygen, and make ATP by respiration in
presence of oxygen.
- Glycolysis is common to fermentation and respiration. In
some facultative anaerobes, the fate of pyruvic acid will be
either fermentation or respiration depending upon the
presence of absence of oxygen.
- Evolutionary Significance of Glycolysis:
- The first prokaryotes probably produced ATP by
glycolysis. Evidence includes the following:
- Glycolysis does not require oxygen, and the
oldest known bacterial fossils date back to three-and-a-half
billion years ago when oxygen was not present in the
atmosphere.
- Glycolysis is the most widespread metabolic pathway, so
it probably evolved early.
- Glycolysis occurs in the cytoplasm and does not require
membrane- bound organelles. Eukaryotic cells with organelles
probably evolved about two billion years after prokaryotic
cells.