Interviews with Judy
Judith Gelman Myers is a freelance writer living in New York. Her essays on film and books appear regularly in American Photo, Hadassah magazine, and First of the Month. She studies flamenco in New York and Jerez and dances and sings weekly at a New York tablao.

The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of this website, (which by the way has no opinions). This is the personal opinion of the author only.

Got a comment about this article? Send it in to chanbny@yahoo.com.

Interview with Daniel Cabrero about his documentary: My Paths Through Dance / Mis Caminos a Través de la Danza at the Dance On Camera Festival

1/26/2012

JGM: Like you, most people know nothing about Spanish dance. As Aida Gomez says, it's a vanishing artform. Why should people be interested in Spanish dance?

DC: Even the Spanish people don't know anything about it. The Spanish dance that Antonia Merce (La Argentina) came up with in 1923 is a very interesting art world, because it comes from the folklore of Spanish dances, but it's actually been developed and evolved through Spanish classical music, from composers like Manuel de Falla, Enrique Granados, Joaquin Torino. They placed their knowledge and experiences and inspirations into the popular culture of the Spanish people. They are short, very interesting and varied, and they use a lot of different styles. Spanish dance combines flamenco, folklore, and bolero school, and that is the most interesting part: variety.

JGM: Mariemma's major contribution was regulating Spanish dance. Why was that necessary

DC: In 1965, the Spanish Dance Society founded in South Africa by Marina Keet (de Grut), among others, actually set up regulations already. When Mariemma did that in 1969, it was necessary for Spanish dance to become academic, because, as you well know from America, things that have an academic base are always more important. In 1933, Manuela Sana proposed this to Antonia Merce and Vicente Escudero, but that actually came to nothing because of the civil war starting in 1936. For Mariemma to have done so after all these years, with the dictatorship, and the repression, and you know, sponsoring Spanish dance in a very propagandistic-like agenda by Franco, maybe that was the best way of doing it, better than actually repressing it. At the same time Mariemma struggled her whole life to get to that, so I think it's very important in many different viewpoints; geographical, folkloric, cultural, political, social. Despite not having made a huge impact on Spanish culture, it's certainly made a huge impact on world dance.

JGM: Enrique Luzuriaga created works for her, but he is barely mentioned in the documentary; in fact, it's difficult to find information on him anywhere. Why does he get so little recognition when in fact their work was almost like duets?

DC: I suppose I'm to blame. Having said that, I felt that the main figure was Mariemma as a dancer. I tried to portray him as very important but the complement to what she was doing.

JGM: Aida Gomez refers to people "fleeing" to flamenco, yet flamenco is an important component of Spanish dance; one of your most fascinating clips is Mariemma dancing with a cantaor.

DC: Flamenco is a very important style, but so is the bolero school of folklore. People like flamenco, people dance flamenco, people walk flamenco, breathe flamenco, but at the same time there are three other legs [of Spanish dance]. It has four limbs, but at the moment we just use one arm or one leg. There is actually one more leg and two more arms that are not being used. In the '40s, '50s, '60s, the masters of the time used to have a combination of the four styles. Now we are very much driven by flamenco because it's the easiest, in a way, to kind of practice, to improvise, with that easiness of saying, Hey, we do flamenco, we can improvise and do some duende stuff, and you don't have to know that much technique and yet you can get away with that. That's what I think she's complaining about. They went through a huge amount of training before acquiring skill that they were able to use properly and profoundly.

JGM: I think that Israel Galvan and El Farruco would disagree with you about technique. [Note: JGM was referring to Antonio Montoya Flores, while Daniel Cabrero is referring to Antonio Fernandez Montoya, Flores's grandson.]

DC: Well, Israel Galvan is actually a dancer. He's been trained as a dancer. His training was very technical. Then he found his own niche. Which I think is actually very important, very interesting as well. It's exciting to have someone like him to be able to do what he is doing performing that improvisational way of dancing but at the same time with technique and background. As far as El Farruco, there are comments all over Spain and people disagree with his way of dancing, but then there's the way he converses with the audience. I suppose it's somehow more to do with how they promote themselves and play that circus of artistic skill and craft. So on the one hand Israel is technically very proficient but goes another way, while Farruco is doing his own stuff and it's working for him and he gets a lot of audiences. I suppose it's a combination of both, the money and the political side of how he portrays himself and not flamenco as a whole.

JGM: You do know that I'm doing this interview for a flamenco website?

DC: Maybe it's better for me to say flamenco is the best thing ever. But I think that flamenco people need to be reminded that there are other styles. They can actually combine it's not a matter of you dancing flamenco and the other styles, but maybe you can dance flamenco and have other people in your company trying to find that way of promoting these styles, because sooner or later, things go in and out of fashion. If flamenco goes out of fashion, the way things are going. Flamenco belongs now to the UNESCO global theme [Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity], yet the other day I was reading in a blog that for the time being the Andalusian government is not fulfilling the requirements that UNESCO is asking for; at the turn of 2013, if they haven't fulfilled that, flamenco might be taken off the list. It's these kind of paradoxes that inspired the Spanish culture. We have something, and because we don't have an enterprising vision, we just lie on what we have and neglect its development. I would like to see what those people are doing in a couple of years' time, see whether flamenco has more impact, the same impact, or people are going to start getting bored and go from time to time to a flamenco show instead of actually making it bigger and bigger.

JGM: In my opinion, flamenco dance is changing into something completely non-flamenco with the recent works of Belen Maya, Maria Pages, Sara Baras, Rocio Molina. Did Mariemma spend much time in the flamenco world? She "discovered" Antonio Canales, Joaquin Cortes, Enrique Morente.

DC: You see what I'm talking about. Flamenco is becoming something of a circus with all of this celebrity-like bullshit, and all that easiness that we Spanish people like and attempt to use in our picaresque. This was something that Cervantes talked about in the seventeenth century. Mariemma was Cortes's first teacher, and she offered Enrique Morente the chance to go to New York, but she didn't spend a lot of time in flamenco because in those years flamenco was something that went hand-in-hand with the other styles. She was more stylized, but she was very keen to dance flamenco as well as she could and put her skill, her uniqueness, into the flamenco world. For me if a flamenco performance is longer than twenty minutes, it becomes very boring. It doesn't keep you alive all the time. The masters combined it with the bolero school. Give me a touch of gentleness and give me the hardness of footwork, but don't give me footwork all the time. Because that's going to be like in the movies; if you give me only high, high, high, my brain cannot bear such a huge amount of strongness or lightness. So just having that bar is a thing that we unfortunately do not understand in Spain; it's always extreme, we are an extreme country, in everything, We are left or right, we are black or white, we are dictatorship or freedom, we have no other term, we have no gray scale, we just have those two main colors, observing colors or reflecting colors, but we don't lift them up as much as we could.

JGM: How did making the film change your view of Spanish history?

DC: It allowed me to see that the arts is something quite neglected in general by Spanish people. We've got this financial credit crisis, yet the cultural side of things in Spain, which is very strong and very exportable to other countries, is not something we see as a business like you Americans do, the English do, the French do. It's allowing me to see those opportunities, as well as to explore and export and enjoy my culture but also to learn about who I am as a Spaniard.

JGM: In your artist's statement you referred to a collective amnesia regarding your country's recent past. How do you account for that collective amnesia?

DC: It's funny how the Spanish people take everything that comes from America, yet we're not able to bear with our own roots, with our own culture, with our own life. It's a shameful thing. In Barcelona, why do supermarkets look like American ones when they should actually have their own personality? American things come over and over and people are embracing them with no realization. It's not a matter of not embracing, it's a matter of looking after what you have, building your own roots more than embracing someone else's stuff.

JGM: You also say that one of the secondary goals of your documentary was showing the personal growth of a woman almost obsessively dedicated to achieving her dream.

DC: That's the main story for me, the universal truth. Almost everyone can relate to what Mariemma went through. At screenings people told me, Yeah, that's happened to me as well, or Yeah, I felt very close to what she was suffering. That was for me the most interesting part, seeing how this child wanted to dance and she ended up as a dancer and died almost dancing, at 91 years of age. You see the last performance of her on the stage in 1992 and you say, God, it was 1926 when she was discovered and it's now 1992 and she's still dancing. Oh, my God, this is a passion, this is fulfillment, overcoming all those obstacles. To me that was amazing. Seeing that life gave me some perspective on what my life could hopefully be in the years to come. It was cool, very cool.

Interview with Martin Santangelo, Noche Flamenca
1/3/2012
During Joe's Pub run, Dec. 30 2011-Jan. 6 2012

JGM: You're trying to do something unusual in flamenco: combining traditional material with contemporary staging and an incredibly high artistic mastery of the form. Talk about what makes the company different from other companies.

MS: One of the things is respecting what theater is. Literally. Physically. When there's anybody onstage, they should be used. They have to be present. Typically flamencos, we don't know much about theater; we usually just have the musicians in the back and call it a day. For me that makes things untrue.

JGM: A lot of dancers of Sole's caliber go off into fusion, but you guys keep it traditional.

MS: If you dig backwards enough, you start getting more interesting, especially in the music and the song. And that allows you to become more experimental. Manuel Gago is one of the two or three singers of his generation who is so immersed in studies of old material, going further and further back into song, into the old singers. He did one letra [at Joe's Pub] that was three hundred years old. And Sole is interested in everything, but I think there's a language that the deeper you go into flamenco, the more you'll get experimental.

JGM: Part of your mission is to educate people about flamenco. Tell me about your workshops and residencies.

MS: I think we're going to open a school in New York. I'm making negotiations with a church to get a space. So one part is the actual education, the classes, and the other part is the shows, where we're always interested in giving equal weight to the singers and the dancers and the musicians. Always. As much as we can.

JGM: You guys have a very longstanding relationship with New York.

MS: Soledad thinks there are very special people in New York. People who see things in an educated way. New Yorkers have seen everything some good, some bad, but everything. And the audience is more open to understanding things, more than almost anywhere else in the world. Maybe not about flamenco, but about art and about what's going on onstage.

JGM: The company has been together for a long time. How does that affect performance?

MS: On one side, it's very good because we know each other and we know what each of us needs to motivate us. On the other hand, sometimes we can fall into a rut thinking that we know what we're doing. So it's very good on one end, on the other it's not.

JGM: Tell me how the show changes over the course of a couple of weeks. What do you tweak, what do you work on?

MS: I'll change positions up, I'll change who sings when without telling the dancers: anything I can do to throw in a monkey wrench to surprise the majority of the group. That way they have to stay on their toes. The big thing, I think, is being completely present, in every show, in the moment. And that's something that's delicious, but intuitively people get into a rut. You get into a routine and you have to fight that intuition that they have so that they're living and breathing something new every night. That's so important. There are things that are mounted, but there are a lot of things that are not mounted. There's a lot of improvisation. But I fight for that improvisation. They get into a routine after two shows, and part of my job is breaking that up, breaking and breaking and breaking. Sole was magnificent last night. She was very surprising.

JGM: People were weeping.

MS: She blew me away.

JGM: Was she happy?

MS: She's never 100 percent happy. Never 100 percent. She came offstage, and I said, "That was beautiful," and she said, "Yeah, but I have to work on this part and this part and this part." And I said, „Oh, come on, Sole." "No, no, tomorrow I just need an hour and a half by myself." You know, "All right, girl."

JGM: She was.well, you know what she was.

MS: What surprised me about last night was that she had many different colors. And that's tough to get to have all those different colors, different emotions that really came out sincerely. I was blown away.

JGM: She does one thing that you don't see a lot. You know the interiority of cante, and how it develops from an internal seed and develops over time. The singers will allow their phrasing to develop. She does that with dance, which is very, very unusual.

MS: Yeah. I think she has a great concept of structure. That's a lot what we work on, Sole and I. Point A to Point B. And the more that we can define Point A and Point B, really define it and go profoundly into it, the more we can develop the road of how to get from Point A to Point B. And that's more and more what I believe allows us to improvise also. Like, if I really work on this moment, and then I really work on the next moment, and then I say, Get from this moment to that moment, how do we do it? How do we get there, musically, vocally, physically, corporally? And she just has a great instinct to structure her beginnings, middles, and ends.

JGM: That's theater, also.

MS: Yes, it's theater.

JGM: It's theater, it's storytelling. To me that sets her dance off from others. I saw Israel Galvan's show [at the Joyce], and his footwork is superb, but that aspect was lacking.

MS: I think he'll mature into it because he's such a well-trained dancer. It matters what road he takes and what he wants to do. He really has a love-hate relationship with flamenco. He almost hates his father, which is tough.

JGM: It's tough when you hate the guy whose footsteps you're walking in.

MS: Exactly. Sometimes he hates it. You have to do a lot of thinking as a dancer, and then not thinking, but you have to do a lot of thinking about the structure of the dance.

JGM: Sole has studied boxing. What else has she studied?

MS: She's studied swimming, with me. She's an athlete. She's ridiculous. I've been swimming a good part of my life. And I have pretty good swimming technique. And I can explain to somebody the technique and they'd have to work on it for six months, seven months. Sole, in a week, gets the technique down and understands it more deeply than I do. She's just physically a genius, also. Her body, physically, is very intelligent. She's an athlete. She's an athlete of the body, but the other thing that comes out is she becomes an athlete of the soul. That's what really begins to come out. Because she'll never do a movement without thinking, What will this bring out of me? or What will this bring out of the music, or What will this communicate through the voice to the audience? She's very intelligent with her body. She's so damn intelligent. There are those people who are athletes, they're wonderful athletes in the real sense of athlete. Not just execution but why are you executing it, and she's extraordinary in that sense.

JGM: She's also an extraordinary teacher.

MS: Yup, she is. She cares a lot, and she's not diplomatic, which cuts through a lot of the bullshit. She's really getting down. And she also believes that technique is more important than choreography. Because she thinks that choreography is not important until you can do the technique. Once you have the technique in your body, then the choreography just comes. Then you can hit whatever choreography.

JGM: Each season is different. How do you vary the program?

MS: I just sit around and think, to be real honest. I would vary it more if I had more time for rehearsal. But I try to do what I can within the time I have.

JGM: Is your time limited because you tour so much?

MS: No, because it's expensive they all live in different parts of Spain. But I have some time during this tour. I have a week, which is a luxury.

JGM: Is there anything that you want to add?

MS: That Gago is one of the pillars of the company. Gago is extraordinarily disciplined, and he just loves the cante. He loves it and is becoming one of the best singers of his generation. He's one of the most knowledgeable, if not the most knowledgeable right now of his generation. He's extraordinary. He's really quite something. I think in five years he's going to be one of the best singers in Spain.

JGM: His type of voice is becoming quite popular right now. That sort of Arcangel, very pure. Tell me about the school.

MS: It's a church on the Upper West Side, and I'm trying to get it for four years. It's going to be a studio and an office space. That's what I'm trying to do. I really want to have a place, to give classes, to rehearse. To have an office.

JGM: That's going to transform flamenco in New York.