Equipment NotebookBackpackSleeping BagTentBootsGaiters -  Cook Gear -  Check List
 

The Backpacking Stove, Cookware & The Water Filter

The Backpacking Stove

Backpacking Stove Although patrol cooking is an important part of scouting, outings are also planned that involve individual or crew (a small group) cooking.  For these times, it is good to have a backpack stove.  As always, there are many types of stoves to choose from but there are certain types that work better for most scouts.

Some of the key considerations are:

1.  Size Considerations

Backpacking stoves come in a variety of sizes -- from lightweight micro-stoves that fit in your pocket to two-burner platforms that barely fit in your trunk.  In general, stick with the lightest, most compact model you can find, unless your plans include short trips, big meals and large groups of people.

To save space and weight in your pack, look for stoves that:

  • Can be disconnected from their fuel supply - Many stoves can be unhooked from external fuel bottles for easier storage in your backpack and less chance of breakage.
  • Fold up/collapse - The legs, base supports and pot holder arms of many backpacking stoves can be collapsed or folded for easier packing.
  • Fit inside of cookware - Some stoves are designed to fit inside of popular cook sets.  This can be a great space-saver (be sure to bring a plastic bag to put your stove in so no fuel spills onto your pots and pans).

2.  Consider Fuel Options

Before you look at specific stove models, take a few minutes to decide which type (or types) of fuel will work best for you.  This will help you narrow down your options:

Butane & butane blends - (Compressed gas)

    Positives
  • Convenient, clean-burning and easy to light.  Burn hot immediately, do not require priming.  Can be adjusted easily for simmering.
  • Can't spill.


  • Negatives
  • More expensive than other fuel types.  You must carry and dispose of the fuel canisters (most are non-recyclable).  Performance may decrease in temperatures below freezing (blended alternatives - Butane/Propane and Isobutane - work better than straight Butane in cold conditions.  Pure propane works well down to 0ºF.  Butane will not work below 32ºF).


  • Overall review
  • Great for warm- to moderate-weather campers who want easy adjustability, few hassles and who don't mind carrying a little extra weight in their packs.
  • This is the best option for a scout because it is the safest and easiest to use.

White gas - (Liquid)

    Positives
  • Inexpensive, easy to find throughout the United States.  Clean, easy to light, spilled fuel evaporates quickly.


  • Negatives
  • Volatile (spilled fuel can ignite quickly), priming is required (fuel from the stove can be used).  Can be hard to find outside of the United States.


  • Overall review
  • A great overall performer, perfect for travel throughout North America in just about any weather conditions.  Reliable, inexpensive and efficient.
  • This is a good option for an adult scouter or a very experienced scout.

Kerosene - (Liquid)

    Positives
  • Inexpensive, easy to find (throughout the world), high heat output, spilled fuel does not ignite easily.


  • Negatives
  • Somewhat messy (burns dirty, smelly). Priming is required (easier if a different priming fuel is used), tends to gum up stove parts.  Spilled fuel evaporates slowly.


  • Overall review
  • A cheap, versatile fuel choice, especially for backpackers who plan on traveling outside of the United States (where white gas and Butane blends may not be readily available).  Not as clean or easy to deal with as butane or white gas.

Denatured Alcohol - (Liquid)

    Positives
  • A renewable fuel resource, low volatility.  Burns almost silently.  Alcohol-burning stoves tend to have fewer moving parts than other types, lowering the chance of breakdown.


  • Negatives
  • Lower heat output, so cooking takes longer and requires more fuel.  Fuel can be hard to find outside of the US and Canada.


  • Overall review
  • A viable, environmentally-friendly option for travel in the US and Canada, especially if you crave peace, quiet and a slow pace on your backpacking trips.

3.  Look For A Stove Design That Works For You

Backpacking stoves come in all kinds of shapes, sizes and designs.  Once you've decided on a general size and fuel type, take a look at your options and ask yourself or someone like a REI salesperson:

  • How easy is the stove to set up?
  • Does it require assembly every time it's used?
  • If so, is the assembly easy or complex?
  • Is the stove sturdy?
  • Is it stable on uneven ground?
  • How hard is it to balance a pot on top?
  • If a gas canister is used, is it easy to attach and remove?
  • Can it be detached before it's completely empty?
  • How easy is the stove to light?
  • Does it require priming?
  • Can it be primed with fuel from the stove itself?
  • How easy is the stove to control?
  • Can the heat output be adjusted easily?
  • Will the stove simmer?
  • How easy is the stove to maintain in the field?
  • Can I handle basic maintenance myself?

4.  Consider Performance

Finally, once you've narrowed down your stove choice to a handful of specific models, consider their overall performance.  A good way to do this is with REI's online stove comparison chart or the in-store printed comparison chart.  Consider variables like:

  • Average boiling time - This measures how hot the stove burns.
  • Water boiled per pint of fuel - This measures how efficient the stove is.  It's like comparing cars based on how many miles-to-the-gallon they get.
  • Burn time at maximum flame - This measures how long the stove will burn on a given supply of fuel before it has to be refilled.

Hints for improving your stove's performance:

  • Use a lid when cooking.
  • Use a windscreen.
  • Use a heat-exchanger on trips of more than a few days (to improve fuel economy).
  • Use alcohol for priming (this will help keep your stove soot-free).
  • Learn how to clean and maintain your stove properly.
  • Use a coffee filter to filter all of your liquid fuel before use.
  • Use the sun or body heat to melt snow (rather than your stove).


CookwareCookware

Most outings in scouts occur over a weekend.  These short trips and simple menus will require the basics only.

  • Single pot, with a lid that can double as a plate
  • Cup
  • Basic utensils (spoon and knife)
  • Some way to pick the pot up (either a handle, bail or pot-grabber)

Water Filter or Purifier

Water Filter As a scout builds has strength and interest in backpacking, a water filter or purifier become a piece of equipment that he will either need to have or be able to share.  It is not a piece of equipment that a new scout needs to purchase.  This being said, lightweight, compact water filters and purifiers have become extremely popular in recent years.  These devices are convenient, easy-to-use and best of all, they're quick.  But how do you choose the right one?

1.  Consider How Much Protection You Want

It's impossible to know for sure if a given water supply is free of contamination.  But bacterial and protozoan contamination has been estimated to be present in 90% of the United States' surface water.  And water-borne viruses may be found anywhere where humans have come into contact with the water supply.

Filters - All of the water filters that REI carries provide reliable protection against bacteria and protozoa (one new model also provides reliable protection against viruses!).  Filters are the easiest, most economical method of making water safe to drink in situations where viral protection is not needed.

A Note on Pore Size
The size of the holes, or "pores", in a filter determine which microorganisms get caught and which sneak through.  Most filters have a small range of hole sizes.  Absolute pore size refers to the size of the largest (least effective) holes.  This measurement tells you which critters will be caught and which won't.

Unfortunately, some manufacturers advertise nominal (average) pore sizes instead of absolute sizes, which can make the whole pore size issue very complex.  When comparing the effectiveness of different filters, concentrate instead on which water-borne nasties the unit claims to eliminate and which it doesn't.

Every water filter (and purifier) that REI sells has packaging that describes which microorganisms it can protect you from.  Be sure to read this information carefully before choosing a specific model.

Purifiers - Water purifiers offer the very best protection available from contaminated water in the backcountry.  Purifiers usually provide reliable protection against bacteria, protozoa and viruses.  But is this extra protection worth the extra cost?  It depends on your plans.

You are at risk for viral infection any time humans have come into contact with your water supply (NOTE: viruses can be spread by everything from urinating to brushing your teeth to spitting in a stream).  This means situations like:

  • Crowded recreation areas where sanitation systems may become overloaded from time to time.
  • Areas where infants may be in the water.
  • Backcountry sites where backcountry visitors may not have disposed of their waste properly.
  • Developing countries with basic sanitation systems.
  • Areas that are susceptible to natural disasters like floods and earthquakes (which could overwhelm sanitation systems).

Quite simply, purifiers are the best choice for any backcountry traveler who doesn't want to take any chances with their water supplies.  Remember -- you never know for sure what's been going on upstream!

2.  Consider How Much Water You'll Need

If you only backpack a few times a year, focus your attention on smaller, less expensive filters/purifiers designed to handle a limited amount of water.  You may need to replace the filter elements in these models from time to time, but you'll still come out ahead in the long run.  If you plan on using your filter/purifier more often (10-20 times a year), it may be more cost effective for you to choose a more expensive unit that's designed to last longer between filter replacements.

Also keep in mind as you compare filter/purifier models that different designs work at different speeds.  If your trip plans involve difficult terrain, dry conditions and/or large groups of people, look for a model that can process a lot of water quickly.  If you're planning shorter trips and/or smaller groups, you maybe happier with a lighter, smaller, less expensive model.

3.  Consider Size and Weight

Keep in mind that you'll be carrying your filter/purifier everywhere you go.  Balance your desire for high water output and ease of use with your desire to keep your backpack light.

4.  Consider Ease of Operation

Water filters/purifiers come in a variety of styles.  When performance levels are similar, the decision between them is often a matter of personal taste.  To decide between models, consider how easy each one is to use.  Ask yourself questions like:

  • How easy is the filter/purifier to set up and operate?  If it's a pump design, how easy is it to pump?
  • Can it be operated easily by a single person?  (try it out for yourself and see!)
  • Is it possible to connect a water container directly to the unit?  If not, how easy is it to get the treated water into your water jug?
  • Can the filter unit be cleaned to extend its usable life?  How easy is it to do?
  • What about basic maintenance procedures? Can common problems be fixed in the field?

NOTE:  If you plan on setting up camp and staying put for a while, you may want to consider a large-volume, gravity-driven system instead of one that you have to pump.  Gravity-driven systems tend to be bulkier and slower than hand-held units.  But they can process a large volume of water while you're out exploring, and you don't have to lift a finger!

5.  Consider Cost

The most expensive water filters/purifiers are often the most cost-efficient when you consider their performance and longevity.  If you plan on backpacking for a number of years, consider paying a little more up front so you can save money further down the trail.  When comparing costs, look at:

  • The overall price of the unit.
  • The amount of water that it can treat before the filter must be replaced.
  • The cost of replacement filter/chemical elements.

Also keep in mind that some filter/purifier elements can be "scrubbed" from time to time to clean out pores and extend their useful life.  Others cannot.

  • Pre-filter - Usually located at the end of the intake hose or just before the main filter.  Pre-filters strain out the largest particles and cut down on wear and tear to your main filter element.  Most pre-filters can be rinsed from time to time to remove caught particles.
  • Depth Filter - These are blocks of filtering material, honeycombed with small passages.  Water flows through the passages and microorganisms are caught inside.  Some depth filters can be cleaned to improve longevity, others cannot.
  • Surface/Membrane Filter - Membrane filters are perforated surfaces that strain out particles as the water passes through.
  • Surface/membrane filters cannot be scrubbed clean.